Showing posts with label Media. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Media. Show all posts

Monday, August 17, 2009

Keeping in touch with the news

An old man reads the Mindanao Examiner newspaper in Zamboanga City in the southern Philippines. Opposition politicians and militant groups urge citizens to stay vigilant and oppose any attempt by the government to impose martial law that can be used to suppress freedom of expression and curtail human rights and eventually prolong President Gloria Arroyo's stay in power beyond 2010 when her term ends. (Photo by Jung Francisco)

Thursday, August 13, 2009

Freedom of Information: Good Theory, Bad Practice

Journalists are among those usually denied access to public information despite the Constitutional guarantee. Information is either confidential or no longer available, leaving them and more so the people clueless on how their country is being run. (Photo by Claire Delfin)

MANILA, Philippines (Philippine Human Rights Reporting Project / August 13, 2009) - In the Philippines, free access to information is guaranteed by the Constitution – but not yet codified by law: The result is the right to information is very much protected in principle – but not in fact. Despite judicial affirmation of such a right, the lack of a clear and defining law has helped to ensure denial of access to official information remains widespread across the country.

The trend has moreover widened under the administration of President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo according to Attorney Nepomuceno Malaluan, co-convenor of the Access to Information Network (ATIN).

“While the long-standing problems cut across all previous regimes, this current administration has displayed an alarming swing towards institutional secrecy,” Malaluan says.

For instance, party-list group Akbayan was met with flat denials to access the text of the proposed agreement during the recent negotiation of the controversial Japan-Philippines Economic Partnership Agreement, a bilateral trade and investment treaty between Japan and the Philippines.

The same also happened to the Transparency and Accountability Network (TAN), which was refused access to the report of retired Supreme Court Chief Justice Hilario Davide Jr. on electoral reforms. The report was seen as significant for TAN, which advocates for electoral reforms.

Malacañang Palace likewise sought to restrict access to the report of the Independent Commission to Address Media and Activist Killings, but eventually gave in after persistent calls from cause-oriented groups.

Denials of access to various government loan agreements and government contracts has been a consistent practice despite a specific provision in the Bill of Rights that requires information on foreign loans obtained or guaranteed by the government to be made available to the public.

Journalists, too

Journalists are not exempted from routine refusals to block access to information despite the country being perceived as enjoying a relatively free press.

“Every journalist who’s had to look for information from public agencies has a horror story to tell -- or at least a frustrating and infuriating tale which usually includes being given the run around and being told outright that certain public records are ‘confidential,’ or that the particular agency just does not release the information being sought,” writes journalism professor Luis Teodoro in his article on access to information - The Key is in the Exemptions.

In most cases, he says, journalists have to settle with non-traditional and informal approaches in getting the required information.

Ed Lingao of the Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism (PCIJ) agrees and adds: “Parang utang na loob mo pang mabigyan ng impormasyon (It’s like you owe them a debt of gratitude if you’re given the information).”

In the last 10 years, PCIJ has documented 14 major instances when they were met with “flimsy excuses” from 12 national agencies in their effort to secure public information relating to its investigative reporting.

In its article entitled “Multiple requests for access to info meet with flat denials,” PCIJ says these requested data and documents included civil work contracts, contractors of government projects, loan agreements, and the assets and liabilities and net worth (SALNs) of justices of the Supreme Court, generals of the Armed Forces and the political appointees of Malacañang and other executive agencies.

Requests for information were made in writing three to five times, and were followed up by as much as 18 to 21 phone calls to the agencies concerned. PCIJ also had to deal with 6 to 9 various officials in the same agencies, and had to wait for 56 days to six months to get any response on its requests.

The situation for those journalists in the provinces is worse. Typically they are referred by local agencies to the national office to obtain public documents.

Things got worse for journalists on February 24, 2006 when President Arroyo issued Presidential Proclamation 1017 which placed the country under a state of emergency amid an alleged plot by “military adventurists.” The order sought to limit the functions of the press to report issues that the government deemed to be precarious to national security.

It went on with a statement from then chairman of the National Telecommunications Commission, Ronald Solis that the government could shut down any television or a radio station during a state of emergency.

President Arroyo lifted the proclamation a week later after reported pressure from economic advisers who maintained the country’s business reputation was suffering.

Red Batario, executive director of the Center for Community Journalism and Development, says information kept secret is a legacy of Marcos martial rule that has lingered on.

Harder for ordinary folks

Ordinary members of the public meanwhile have an even harder time securing their rights to public information than journalists.

“The poor are still chained to the shackles of ignorance. Aside from organized citizens groups and people’s organizations, a large majority of poor Filipinos are unable to claim their rights simply because they don’t know how, and what these are, to begin with,” writes Batario in his article “Our Right to Know.”

Batario adds that information, when democratized and made widely available, allows citizens to actively participate on issues that have serious repercussions for governance.

“The ouster of Joseph Estrada midway through his presidency illustrates the potent power of the information when citizens, shocked by the proceedings of the impeachment trial covered extensively by the press, took the streets to call for his resignation.”

But Batario also lauds certain practices in some places in the Philippines. The Ulat sa Banwaan (Report to the People) of Albay province and Batad in Iloilo are few examples of how active citizen participation has opened up information flows and helped to ensure greater transparency in local government processes.

Information Law

But as these models come in extremely short supply, a Freedom of Information Act becomes necessary, says ATIN.

It adds it is only through an informed press and citizenry that Filipinos can effectively and reasonably participate at all levels of social, political and economic decision-making.

The proposed law was passed in the House of Representatives last year, but it has languished in the Senate.

Among others, House Bill 3732 provides clear, uniform, and speedy procedure for public access to information. It also provides mechanics for the compulsory duty of government agencies to disclose information on government transactions.

The bill enumerates a narrow list of clearly defined and reasonable exceptions. While the general rule is that all information in the hands of government must be accessible to the public, it adds that there are times when it is in the public interest to keep some information confidential – for example ongoing criminal operations.

But the bill also allows an opportunity and right for citizens to override an exception whenever there is greater public interest in the disclosure of information.

It provides clear criminal liabilities for violation of the right to information, and at the same time, adequate and accessible remedies when cases of this nature arise.

And more importantly, the bill spells out numerous mechanisms for the active promotion of openness in government, which is seen as a vital safeguard against rampant corruption that has weighed down the country’s economic performance.

“Secrecy in government has given public officials a wide room for maneuver and greater cover for corruption,” says ATIN’s Malaluan. It is widely reported and accepted that more than 20 per cent of the country’s annual budget is lost to corruption and mismanagement, thanks to an annual budget process that is so lacking in transparency and oversight.

Nevertheless, ATIN remains optimistic that the bill can still be passed before the 14th Congress ends next year. The Senate may be lacklustre and sluggish but it does not, so far, harbour any strong opposition against the bill.

And that is a good sign for advocates to push the bill’s passage much forward. After all, there is no better time -- than now -- to claim that most basic of rights, the right to information.(By Claire Delfin. The author is a television news reporter of GMA Network, Inc. and is a regular contributor of special reports on women, children, education, health, human rights, and the environment to the network’s news website GMANews.TV.)


Link: http://www.rightsreporting.net/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=6998&Itemid=130

Thursday, December 04, 2008

The Mindanao Examiner - All Rights For Sale


ALL RIGHTS FOR SALE
We are moving to film and television productions!
Mindanao Examiner Newspaper



(Website Contents, Office Inventory Included)


Contact Us:
+63 62 9925480
+63 915 2756606

Monday, November 03, 2008

Reporter hits harassment by Army colonel

COTABATO CITY, Philippines (Philippine Daily Inquirer / Nov. 3, 2008) - A radio reporter here has complained of harassment by an Army colonel who allegedly berated him for entering the 6th Infantry Division at the height of a fire that razed an ammunition dump Friday.

“He was yelling at me, his eyes as if on fire, and berated me when he found me inside the camp near the ammunition dump,” Loreto Rosario of Church-run Radio DXMS, told the Philippine Daily Inquirer (parent company of INQUIRER.net).

He identified the official as Lt. Col. Aswald Buco, 6th ID camp commander.

Buco could not be reached for comment but Col. Julieto Ando, 6th ID spokesperson, apologized for and in behalf of Buco.

“I would like to apologize to Mr. Rosario,” Ando said, adding that the situation at the time of the fire was “high and there was a state of confusion.”

Ando explained that Buco was the camp commander and he would like to make sure nobody who was not allowed at the camp could come closer to the ammunition dump where the fire started at 4:15 a.m.

“There’s no problem if I was told to distance myself from the fire scene,” according to Rosario. “What dismayed me was his yelling at me as if I am his subordinate, as if I am a criminal, as if I did not present my press card.”

“You are an intruder, it’s good that my men did not shoot you,” Rosario quoted Buco as telling him. “If they have shot me, that was their problem, I did not violate any rule,” he said.

Rosario maintained that he came to the camp as a reporter with proper identification cards to report what was going on when there was a 30-minute powerful and continuous explosion.

“I coordinated with Maj. Abaja, deputy spokesperson, and he allowed me entry,” Rosario said.
“Besides, the main gate was open when I arrived so I proceeded to the fire scene,” Rosario, who has been covering the 6th ID beat for the past five years, said.

Rosario also accused Buco of taking his two mobile phones and press card and handed them over to his men. But Rosario grabbed them and left. He proceeded to the office of Ando.

Buco, with his heavily armed bodyguards in tow, followed Rosario at Ando’s office.

There he berated Rosario anew in front of Ando and accused him of being an “intruder.”
Ferdinand Cabrera, secretary general of National Union of Journalists of the Philippines-Cotabato chapter, condemned Buco’s actuation and called for an investigation.

“That was very unprofessional and uncalled for an Army officer,” Cabrera said.
It was the second case of media harassment inside the 6th ID.

Last week, about 10 policemen assigned with the police station of Mother Kabuntalan, Shariff Kabunsuan were berated and given a dressing down by an Army lieutenant of the 6th Infantry Battalion.

The Army lieutenant, known as Lt. Capuyan, has been relieved and is undergoing investigation, according to Ando. (Edwin O. Fernandez - Philippine Daily Inquirer)

Saturday, August 09, 2008

Capiz Radioman's Murder Mocks Government's Claims: NUJP

The murder in broad daylight of Capiz broadcaster Martin Roxas on Thursday, August 7, mocks government's claims that it has brought down the incidence of extrajudicial killings, particularly the murder of journalists.

Roxas, 32, is the fourth journalist murdered this year and the 59th since President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo came to power in 2001.

The brazenness with which he was slain and the short span of time since another colleague, General Santos broadcaster Dennis Cuesta, was shot and grievously wounded in another daytime attack, merely show that the culture of impunity the government has helped nurture by its inaction, apathy and even its outright attempts to stifle press freedom, continues to thrive.

Roxas was chased and gunned down as he left the station after his program at around 1 p.m. Thursday. He died in a hospital about an hour later from a gunshot to the spine.

Roxas was the program director of Radio Mindanao Network's dyVR and auditor of the Capiz chapter of the National Union of Journalist of the Philippines.

NUJP members in General Santos and Davao City joined the protest action held this afternoon in General Santos while NUJP-Iloilo has organized a mass. Similar actions are being planned in other areas, including Manila.

As we grieve the loss of yet another colleague, we call on all independent Filipino journalists to remain steadfast in our mission of serving the people by delivering to them the information they will need in molding their individual and collective futures.(http://www.nujp.org)

Saturday, November 10, 2007

Corruption, Greed And Love For Money...

MANILA, Philippines (Mindanao Examiner / Nov. 10, 2007)- They say greed and money poison the mind, then the heart is also corrupted. An article published by one of the Philippines' oldest and most respected daily, The Manila Times, tells a story of how journalists in Olongapo City accused each other of corruption.

And this happens everywhere in the country, where many journalists fall victims to corruption and illegal activities and all because of dirty money.

Here is the Manila Times story written by correspondent Anthony Bayarong.

OLONGAPO CITY: Journalists here denounced the allegations of a tabloid correspondent accusing them of protecting an illegal gambling or peryahan at the Subic Bay Freeport and in this city.

The allegations appeared in People’s Journal on November 2, 4 and 5, written by Johnny Reblando who is also an RMN news correspondent. He alleged that members of the press covering Subic Bay Freeport provide operators of illegal gambling an ample protection.

Members of the Subic Bay Press Corps (SBPC) said they are concerned about the allegations because the group is the biggest organization of correspondents, with more than 40 members in its roster.

The SBPC has repeatedly asked Reblando to name the alleged media protectors, but he declined, saying, “Kung sino ang pumiyok, guilty [Whoever reacts would be guilty].”

By declining to name names or provide convincing evidence, Reblando made suspects out of all media practitioners, which is wrong, unfair, unethical and unacceptable, maintained the SBPC statement.

According to SBPC, amusement center owner Avelino Menor, in a sworn statement dated November 6, said Reblando harassed him for P20,000.

Menor added that he had been giving Reblando money for “merienda and cell-phone loads” since 2005 which, if proven true, would be contrary to ethical standards of a journalist.

In his sworn statement, Menor said that he had given Reblando P10,000 on October 14 and that the next payment would be on the 15th of November, but Reblando allegedly called Menor on October 30 asking for the remaining balance of P10,000. When Menor could not produce the money, Reblando went ahead with his exposé on illegal gambling at the Subic Freeport and the city.

The sequence of events, as described by Menor, is a classic extortion scheme known to media practitioners as “attack and collect/defend and collect” (AC/DC).

The SBPC is investigating the matter although journalists here urged the Journal Group, RMN Manila and the National Press Corps to initiate its own investigation. (Mindanao Examiner)

Tuesday, June 05, 2007

SPECIAL: Newspapers Must Embrace Digital Future To Survive

CAPE TOWN - Newspapers hoping to retain their readers and survive in the technological age must venture into the online and mobile phone spheres, a World Association of Newspapers (WAN) meeting heard Tuesday.

Speakers at a workshop said the newspaper was a dying breed but could avoid extinction by modernizing its approach and extending its digital reach.

"We have to learn that online is where the action is, and we have to move our journalistic resources there," Mario Garcia, chief executive of the United States-based Garcia Media Group, told delegates to the WAN's 60th world newspaper congress and 14th world editors' forum being held in Cape Town.

He described the new path of news, starting with an e-mail or mobile phone alert of a breaking story, followed by reading it online and ending in its publishing in a newspaper the following day.

In such a scenario, he said, there was little point in newspapers repeating the news hours after it first broke. They would have to learn to present readers with new, forward-looking story angles.

"Nowadays, you have to assume that the reader knows more than you do," he said.

Martha Stone, director of the WAN's "shaping the future of the newspaper" program, told delegates the time has come for news organizations to cross-train journalists to tell a story in print, radio, television or online.

"Many newspapers experience today their circulations going down, but their reach into the market place with the internet is surging," she said.

Leonard Brody, chief executive and co-founder of NowPublic.com, a website for "citizen journalism" with over 90,000 contributors in ordinary people worldwide, believed the monopoly of traditional media was being challenged by camera phones and other technology enabling anyone to find news.

"We are moving very quickly into an era where everything is being recorded," he told the meeting.

On Monday, a WAN report said newspapers around the world saw a 2.3 percent rise in circulation in 2006 and a growth in advertising revenue despite the rise of digital media. (We are reposting this article by the international news agency, Agence France-Presse, to help bring awareness about the power of the Internet in today's media. Ed.)

Wednesday, May 09, 2007

Stop Linking Islam To Terrorism, Media Told

GENERAL SANTOS CITY – A nephew of Moro Islamic Liberation Front’s former chairman Sheikh Hashim Salamat has assailed the press people’s “use of the term terrorism, linking it to Islam,” asseverating that “the education and economic development of the Bangsamoro are the most effective solutions to the decades-long armed conflict that have confronted Mindanao.”

“Everyday, we see a lot of bad news on television, read discouraging news in the papers, and hear about the same in the radio. Quite sadly but is the reality, many of those bad news, particularly those that dwell on violence, peace and order problems, terrorism particularly, are linked to the Muslims, to the people of my faith,” said banana plantation tycoon Datu Ibrahim “Toto” Paglas III, former mayor of the municipality of Datu Paglas in Maguindanao.

However, he clarified that, “Those who do so unfortunately misunderstand Islam but then we do not blame them for their innocent, mistaken belief.”

Paglas said it is a challenge to Muslims “to show that we are just like any other people on earth who wish to live in peace and harmony, who wish to see a better life for ourselves and our families, who submit to the will of the one and only creator, the God of all, without discrimination as to race, religion, and creed.”

“If only we are economically developed, if only our poor brothers and our poor villages and lands are productive, if we are able to trade and do business with others, then we can co-exist with more pride and self-respect,” he said.

“If only our poor brothers are better educated and adequately provided economically, then they can no longer be a fertile breeding ground to terrorism and other form of criminality and lawlessness.”

Speaking in a gathering of young Moro professionals in a hotel here, Paglas asserted that education and entrepreneurship “could be an effective approach to peace building” and “could be an effective means of changing our negative image before the world, and even before our very own selves.”

“This can be our legacy to our succeeding generations who we definitely do not wish to go through the kind of difficult times that we at present, starting from the time of our ancestors, have been suffering from until now.”

“Our poor villages have actually been blessed with their own, respective richness, a blessing from Allah, which is basically the bounty of nature, whether they be in our lands, or seas, or lakes, or rivers.”

“As important as the need to make them productive, is the need to keep them sustainable,” he said.

Paglas said the rebel group’s late leader had advised him three guiding principles “when I consulted with him about my decision to let investments come in” in his native town of Datu Paglas.

These are: protect the environment at any cost because this is all we have for the next generation; do not abuse the workers, protect their rights and look after their welfare and safety; and provide education for the children.

Paglas claimed, the first principle “allowed me to operate in a way that is acceptable not only to my international shareholders while it also looked after my moral obligation to the community and the future generation, to ensure preservation of our resources.”

He said the second principle “allowed me to work within the parameters not only of government regulations but a commitment as well to the teachings of God, thru His different Messengers and lived by different religions.”

As to the third principle, Paglas said, “I will continue to invest in the future of our children. I believe and I have seen this myself that poverty and economic inequality are a fertile breeding ground for terrorism.”

“A healthy and well-educated generation will be the most positive and powerful tool against terrorism, and for the preservation of earth’s resources,” Paglas said, adding that “As the saying of the Wise goes, we did not simply inherit this world from our parents, the better truth is that: we merely borrowed this world from our children.”

Paglas admitted that through the said principles “I learned that a clear sense of vision and mission helps clarify and purify our intentions” because “I was not born poor although ever since my younger days I had always found natural affinity with the house helpers, drivers and bodyguards of my parents” and “I had seen the glaring divide that separated the Muslim nobilities from the common families.”

“I protested the norms where the leadership of the ruling clans put their interest over the most basic concerns of those in poverty” and “vowed to use the influence of my family to make a difference in our community because I was tired of seeing the same vicious cycle of violence and poverty,” he said.

Paglas disclosed that “I wanted to try something new because the traditional Muslim way of leading our people was not working. It worked for the elite Muslim families and the politicians. But it never worked for the people.”

“I also learned that in fulfilling my mission to bridge the economic, social, and political divide among the tri-peoples in Mindanao, the Muslims, Christians, and Highlanders, I knew I had to change the rules of the game,” he said.

The former mayor said that “When the convention dictates that the Datus or members of the local royal families are the only people who can make sound decisions for the people, I encouraged dialogue and consensus among local folks. By doing so, we share the accountability to make things work for all of us.”

Paglas said that because the “Philippine Muslim culture is basically very exclusive, I challenged that by bringing everyone’s concerns on the table, the government, the military, the religious leaders, the workers, the rebels and even the lawless elements because I believe that what each of these groups say is of great value.”

However, “We often had difficulty welcoming new ideas and new ways. We did not want outsiders in our territory. But again, this system did not work for us and therefore, I invited NGOs and the academe to work with us so that we could learn how to invest in our future through training, skills building, values formation and education.”

“We built partnerships with as many groups as possible, regardless of culture, faith, ideologies, to hasten the progress we deserve and dreamed for,” he added.

“I was brought up in a culture where guns and goons define a Man’s status in the society. I challenged that convention,” Paglas disclosed.

He revealed that he went around Datu Paglas without my bodyguards but at first “I was not comfortable because it was not the normal thing.”

“But, I decided to put an end to that fashion because the old ways were not working for others and for me either,” he continued.

The 47-year old businessman however revealed that “My personal campaign took a toll on me.”

“I lost my father and three brothers due to violence and lawlessness, before I could demonstrate to the rest that we don’t need guns. Other traditional and political leaders are still relentless, but I keep the faith that in due time they will change.”

Paglas disclosed that “I was brought up in a culture of ‘eye for an eye and tooth for a tooth’” and “Throughout my growing years, I was witness to vengeance killings we call ‘rido’ among clans, perpetuated throughout the succeeding generations.”

“In the pursuit of my business plan, and inspired by my late uncle former MILF Chairman Hashim Salamat, I decided that this culture of hatred and cycle of violence must stop,” Paglas said, adding that “when my father and younger brothers became murder victims, I decided to accept that it was their fate, their time had come, God had Allowed it to happen, and I must forgive. I left justice to the laws and to the authorities.”

“Today we are starting to reap the fruits of our labor and faith for a better future,” the banana plantation tycoon said.

“By way of infusing at least $400,000 dollars to the local economy every month in the form of salary for the more than 2,000 full time plantation workers and allied economic activities versus almost nothing in the past, we are able to change the picture of Datu Paglas town from war zone to economic zone.”

“For me, the bigger challenge is always how to sustain the gains. And my simple but honest response to this is to continue to listen to what other people have to say, and listen from the wisdom of their stories as they gave me great inspiration to continue to improve, to be a better leader,” he added.

“The investment that we established in Datu Paglas allowed us Muslims to prove our worth, whether it be as a leader, as a follower, as an employer, as a worker, as a professional, or simply as a responsible citizen in out communities. We earned the trust of our investors. Recently, my investors conveyed their approval of up to U.S. $50 million additional investment to expand our operations to 2,300 more hectares in, to the surprise of many, the risky Muslim area, including the predominantly Maranao mountain town of Bumbaran, and its adjoining town of settlers, in Wao, both towns in the province of Lanao del Sur,” he continued.

Paglas said he is proud that “The expansion areas have been in the headlines because of the armed conflict between military and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front, and plain lawlessness.”

“But now this town is looking forward to having its own share of peace and prosperity, for the benefit of their children. This new investment and development means employing at least 3,000 more people and I am glad to know that thousands of rebels took advantage of the opportunity to be in the mainstream workforce,” Paglas said. (Norodin M. Makalay)