MANILA, Philippines (Mindanao Examiner / August 19, 2009) – Marines have killed 7 members of the former Muslim rebel group called Moro National Liberation Front in a firefight Wednesday on a small island they occupied in Palawan province in western Philippines, the military said.
It said soldiers stormed the island of Matangule off Palawan province and liberated villagers held by former rebels. It was unclear why the gunmen led by MNLF leader Abdullah Abdurajak occupied the island, but the military said the former rebels had held hostage dozens of civilians since Sunday for a still unknown reason.
The hostages were later freed, but the rebels, numbering about five dozens, refused to surrender peacefully and opened fire on soldiers sent to liberate the villagers and a firefight ensued. One soldier was also wounded in the fighting.
The military said two gunmen were also captured during the fighting, but others escaped despite the presence of navy patrol boats around the island, home to a few thousand Muslims, mostly fishermen.
The MNLF, under Nur Misuari, signed a peace deal with Manila in September 1996 and ending decades of bloody war. After the peace agreement was signed, Misuari became the governor of the Muslim autonomous region. But despite the peace accord, there was a widespread disillusionment with the weak autonomy they were granted.
Under the peace accord, Manila would have to provide a mini-Marshal Plan to spur economic development in Muslim areas in the South and livelihood and housing assistance to tens of thousands of former rebels to uplift their poor living standards.
Misuari is facing rebellion charges after his followers tried, but failed to occupy a major military base in Sulu province in the southern Philippines and another group held hostage over 100 people in Zamboanga City in 2001 in an attempt to stop the elections in the Muslim autonomous region.
Misuari fled to Sabah, his former refuge, but was arrested by the Malaysian authorities and sent back to Manila. Misuari is currently out on bail.
The MNLF Central Committee removed Misuari as chairman of the former rebel group and installed Muslimin Sema, the Front’s Secretary-General. But Misuari insisted that he is still the chieftain of the MNLF and accused Sema, also the mayor of Cotabato City, as traitor and so were those who supported Sema.
Last year, Misuari earned the ire of the Malaysian government after he renewed calls of the claims of the Philippines to Sabah. In retaliation, Sabah Progressive Party President Datuk Yong Teck Lee, furious over the rumblings from Misuari, has called for stricter laws on Filipinos traveling to the oil-rich state. (Mindanao Examiner)
Wednesday, August 19, 2009
Troops liberate Philippine island after firefight with gunmen
Davao Media Interview Philanthropist Karlo Nograles


Rebels raid budget hotel in Mindanao
DAVAO CITY, Philippines (Mindanao Examiner / August 19, 2009) – Philippine communist rebels raided a budget hotel and restaurant and seized weapons allegedly being by its owners to threaten peasants in the southern province of Bukidnon.
Isabel Santiago, a spokeswoman for the New People’s Army Herminio Alfonso Command, said rebel forces also ambushed pursuing soldiers and policemen in the village of Kipolot in Kitaotao town, but there were no reports of government casualties.
She said the rebels raided the Travelers Inn and Restaurant on Monday as a punishment for its owner, the Nietes family, for allegedly threatening peasants in the village.
“The Nietes family was disarmed as punishment for keeping high-powered firearms they used to threaten peasant civilians,” Santiago said.
“Violations of regulations on business operations inside guerrilla territories were the reasons for the punitive action on the Nietes establishment. The action was undertaken mainly to confiscate firearms, of which, one Uzi machine pistol was seized,” she added.
But the Army’s 10th Infantry Division said rebels raided the inn and robbed its owners of more than P20, 000 in cash and a pistol.
Captain Rosa Maria Cristina Manuel, an army spokesperson, said the rebels also took a civilian hostage who was later freed. “These people are terrorists who would take advantage of the weak. Troops are tracking down the NPA terrorists,” she said.
The NPA denied Manuel’s accusations and said rebels did not take any money. “As a matter of policy, the NPA do not take cash from punished targets. The allegations of are all lies,” Santiago said.
Major General Reynaldo Mapagu, commander of the 10th Infantry Division, condemned the raid. “The evil tactics employed by these terrorists show their inhuman and ungodly motives. The use of improvised explosive device as landmine and the use of civilians as human shields are clear violations of International Humanitarian law and against every conceivable moral standard worldwide. More so, robbing a fast food is pure felony.”
“We can clearly see that these local terrorists do not have any ideology at all. They are plain criminals who fester on the weak and take advantage of issues to advance their selfish motives,” he said.
He said the rebels last week also held hostage four civilians, including an 11 year-old girl, and used them as shield against government troops before they ransacked a military detachment in the village of Napungas in Davao Del Norte’s Asuncion town.
The NPA is the armed wing of the outlawed Communist Party of the Philippines which is currently negotiating peace with Manila. The rebels have been fighting the past four decades for the establishment of a Maoist state in the country. (Mindanao Examiner)
Two Warring Sulu Muslim Clans End Fighting; Sign Peace Covenant
ZAMBOANGA CITY, Philippines (Mindanao Examiner / August 19, 2009) – Two prominent Muslim clans engaged in bloody feud in the southern Filipino province of Sulu have signed a peace covenant ending four years of hostilities.
The Caluang-Halun clans signed the peace covenant during a thanksgiving ceremony held in Zamboanga City over the weekend. The ceremony was attended by over 200 mostly clan elders and members led by former Mayor Al Hussein Caluang and Hajji Peping Halun, village chieftain of Pitogo in Kalingalan Caluang town.
Both Caluang and Halun are prominent clans in the towns of Kalingalan Caluang and Luuk in Sulu, according to Commissioner Mukattil Adjail, of the Regional Reconciliation and Unification Commission in the Muslim autonomous region.
“The covenant signed by the Caluang and Halun clans will surely bring peace in Sulu and stop the hostilities between the two sides,” Adjail told the Mindanao Examiner.
He said the feud started when in November 2005, Don Caluang, who was a former mayor in Kalingalan Caluang town, was killed in Zamboanga City. The succeeding retaliations between the two clans left two dozen people dead and 14 injured from both sides.
“This reconciliation was made possible through the efforts of Governor Zaldy Ampatuan, the Regional Reconciliation and Unification Commission of Sulu province and local non-governmental organizations, the United Youth of the Philippines–Women, Inc. and Sakayan Mindanao, with the support of The Asia Foundation and United States Agency for International Development,” Adjail said.
Ampatuan, who is actively involved in the settlement of clan feuds, is the governor of the Muslim autonomous region to which Sulu belongs. While The Asia Foundation funded meetings and other activities related to the peaceful resolutions of clan feuds, Adjail said.
In a separate statement, Dr Steven Rood, Country Representative of The Asia Foundation said: “As the Holy Month of Ramadan approaches some time next week, this celebration of reconciliation between the Caluang and Halun families is truly a blessing and an inspiration for all of us.”
“This reconciliation of the two families is inspirational because it is a shining example of a path to peace attained through hard work, sincere dialogue, and genuine forgiveness,” he added.
Clan war or locally known as “rido” is common in many parts of the southern Philippines and so far had resulted in the killings of more than 5,000 people over the past seven decades. (Mindanao Examiner)
Under Oath, Under Threat: Committee to Protect Journalists Special Report


Images: Family photo of Dennis Cuesta and Marcelo Pintac, director of police for General Santos City, who says that apprehending the lead suspect is not as easy as it might seem. And a banner outside Cuesta’s radio station calls for justice. Station manager Alex Josol says he is skeptical of police work in the case.(CPJ Photo / Shawn W. Crispin) In the Philippines, witnesses to journalist murders face extreme pressures and grave risk. The government’s protection program, while valuable, falls short of ensuring justice.
GENERAL SANTOS CITY, Philippines (CPJ / August 19, 2009) - When motorcycle-riding assailants shot and fatally wounded Dennis Cuesta along a busy, tree-lined highway here last year, friend and fellow Radio Mindanao Network reporter Bob Flores was walking by his side.
Flores recalls Cuesta’s body being flung into his own as one gunman fired three times at close range. As Cuesta dropped to the side of the road, a second assailant fired twice more, inflicting head injuries that contributed to the 38-year-old journalist’s death five days later, on August 9, 2008.
In a twist familiar in journalist killings in the Philippines that allegedly involve wayward public officials, local police initially labeled Flores a suspect rather than a witness. “They said I was the No. 1 suspect in the crime,” Flores told CPJ, recounting what police told him in the immediate aftermath of the murder. “I knew then my life would never be the same.”
Within days, Flores received an anonymous text message threatening to harm his family if he testified in the murder case. Fearful but determined not to back down, Flores entered the government’s Witness Protection Program (WPP) on August 15, 2008, and he, his wife, and three young children were placed in a safe house in the capital, Manila.
It was only there and then, in hiding with state-appointed bodyguards more than 1,000 kilometers from the crime scene, that Flores felt secure enough to make a sworn statement to investigators identifying Police Chief Inspector Redempto “Boy” Acharon, first cousin of the mayor of General Santos City, Pedro Acharon Jr., as the second gunman in Cuesta’s killing.
"An unserved arrest warrant"
A local court issued an arrest warrant in April for Redempto Acharon and two other suspects, but as of August, police in this city of 500,000 on the island of Mindanao had yet to carry out the order.
Since the warrant was issued, local journalists said, Acharon has been spotted dining in local restaurants and doing chores at his residence in General Santos City. “He’s not free to roam around, but he doesn’t want to surrender or be arrested until all legal issues are resolved,” said Rogelio Garcia, Acharon’s lawyer, who insisted that his client was not guilty of the crime. “We are exploring all legal avenues to protect the interests of my client.”
Fear of reprisals causes many potential witnesses to look the other way in violence-prone areas of the Philippines, allowing for a culture of impunity to thrive. The island nation placed sixth on CPJ’s 2009 Impunity Index, which ranks countries in which journalists are slain regularly and governments fail to solve the crimes. According to CPJ research, at least 24 Philippine journalists’ murders have gone unsolved over the last decade.
The circumstances surrounding Cuesta’s murder conform to a disturbing pattern in this country: a journalist is shot and killed; local police manipulate the evidence to protect influential people accused in the crime; potential witnesses are intimidated, bought off, or killed so that they never appear in court; the defense employs stalling tactics to break the will of remaining witnesses; the case goes unsolved and the culture of impunity is reinforced.
One key to breaking the cycle of violence, public prosecutors and media freedom advocates say, is better care and protection of witnesses. According to Senior State Prosecutor Leo Dacera, who heads the WPP, about 40 witnesses to media-related killings and another 120 of their family members are now enrolled in the program. That constitutes about a quarter of the nearly 600 people enrolled overall in the program, which covers witnesses to crimes involving criminal syndicates, terrorism, narcotics, and human trafficking. He said the WPP is under-financed, receiving 83 million pesos (US$1.7 million) in 2008.
Philippine President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo has acknowledged the financial shortfall and promised this year to increase the program’s funding to more than 140 million pesos. But the promised funds have not materialized because of political squabbling in the legislature, which has the final say over budget allocations, according to Dacera. The lack of funds, WPP administrators say, makes witnesses vulnerable to threats or bribes intended to have them recant their testimony or simply not appear in court.
The Cuesta case underscores the importance and shortcomings of the Philippine protection program. It also highlights the wider need to transfer murder cases in which local officials are implicated from local courts to more neutral and secure jurisdictions. Public prosecutors in the Cuesta case have already filed a motion with the Supreme Court to transfer the case to Manila, which would allow for better protection of witnesses in the case.
That security, however, comes at a heavy price: Witnesses must be willing to make extraordinary sacrifices in the pursuit of justice. The Manila-based Center for Media Freedom and Responsibility has recently spotlighted the crucial role of witness protection in combating media killings. “When we got involved with the prosecution of cases, it opened a whole new area of advocacy concerns,” said Melinda DeJesus, the center’s executive director. “These people actually lose their lives. They don’t—and won’t—know life as they knew it before, once they enroll in a witness protection program.”
"Sacrificing their lives"
Flores is a dramatic case in point. He and his family now live in a WPP-maintained safe house that they share with two other witnesses to media-related killings. Barred by the program from keeping a mobile telephone that could be used to trace his whereabouts, Flores has had to stop working as a journalist. Protected by bodyguards, he spends his time watching television, reading books, and worrying about the safety of his children, who attend a nearby school. He regrets that the 8,000 pesos (US$160) he receives monthly from the program is seldom enough to meet his family’s daily needs.
“I have sacrificed my family, my job, everything for justice,” said the 49-year-old Flores, who worked with Cuesta for more than a decade before his murder. Even if Acharon and the other two suspects were eventually convicted in Cuesta’s killing, Flores said he would never feel safe returning to his home in Davao City, about 120 kilometers from General Santos City. “When the case is over, we will have to start a new life somewhere else,” he said.
The meager lifestyle afforded by the WPP has jeopardized the testimony of at least one other witness in the Cuesta case. Referred to by WPP officials as “Lance,” the young male witness said he was riding his motorcycle on the highway when he saw Cuesta’s killing. Local journalists were the first to publish the young man’s statement; he was later located by WPP officials and encouraged to enroll in the program.
But he has twice left WPP safe houses and, according to Department of Justice officials, was on his own somewhere in Mindanao when CPJ researched this report in July. “We’re afraid if we don’t find him first, the other side will,” said Al Calica, a public prosecutor and WPP administrator in central Mindanao who travels with four armed bodyguards of his own. “We’re afraid they’ll either try to buy him off or kill him off.”
If history is a guide, Calica’s concerns are well warranted. The case of radio journalist Edgar Damalerio, who was shot and killed in 2002, demonstrates the danger of serving as a witness in a media killing. Two witnesses in the case were killed before they could testify, and a third survived an assassination attempt. One of the slain witnesses had been first approached with a bribe to dissuade him from testifying. The gunman in the case, former police officer Guillermo Wapile, was finally convicted in 2005 and sentenced to life imprisonment.
In other instances, witnesses are paid by powerful defendants to change their testimony. The ongoing court proceedings in the murder of journalist Herson Hinolan may be a case in point. Two state witnesses who initially identified former Lezo Mayor Alfredo Arcenio as Hinolan’s assassin have since recanted their testimony. One of those witnesses had enrolled in the WPP, but later dropped out of the program. In February, the Visayan Daily Star quoted public prosecutor Dacera as saying that the defense had intimidated and offered money to witnesses. Arcenio disputed the accusation.
Witnesses who stay in the WPP are not necessarily out of harm’s way. When assailants shot and severely wounded radio journalist Nilo Laberes in March, he became a witness in his own case. After identifying one of the gunmen as a protector of a local gambling racket, Laberes took refuge in a WPP safe house—only to have local police overrun the sanctuary to press charges against him for illegal gambling. (In his reports, Laberes had not only exposed the gambling operation, he had accused police of being involved.)
Laberes has since filed a request with the Supreme Court to transfer the attempted murder trial of his assailants from Cagayan de Oro City to Manila. The journalist, who lost a kidney as a result of injuries suffered in the attack, now lives in another WPP-administered safe house. The gambling charges against him were not pursued.
Government attempts to address impunity in journalist killings have fallen short thus far. A national police initiative known as Task Force USIG was created on the orders of President Arroyo in 2006 to investigate and resolve media killing cases. Although task force records show that police have filed charges in most journalist killings since 2001, the records also show authorities have gained convictions in only three cases.
Police Chief Inspector Henry Libay, a task force member, said in an interview with CPJ that the mishandling of evidence and the lack of willing witnesses are the main impediments to success. He said witnesses shy from testifying out of fear of reprisal, lack of financial support, and a distrust of law enforcement.
"You’ll be next"
That lack of trust is apparent in General Santos City, said Alex Josol, the 42-year-old manager of the Radio Mindanao Network station where Cuesta worked and reported until his death. Showing CPJ the exact spot at the side of the road where Cuesta was slain, Josol noted that several coconut vendors were within sight of the murder that day. “They were all gone the next day and never returned,” Josol said. “Nobody wants to testify for fear of retaliation.”
That was also the case when Jo Jo Morales, another reporter at his station, was shot and killed on the way home from work in 2005. “Just like in Cuesta’s case,” Josol said, “the accused was not arrested.”
Because Cuesta reported on a wide range of sensitive issues, Josol said it was hard to pinpoint which report might have prompted the murder—although he noted that Cuesta’s reports on illegal gambling touched on potential police involvement. Cuesta also criticized the mayor for city hall’s slow implementation of flood prevention projects, he said.
“After one year, the police have done nothing to arrest the suspect because the accused is connected to the mayor,” Josol said. “There have been many instances when the suspect was seen inside his house, at restaurants, on the street, and he still remains free. We report this on the radio and call on national authorities to intervene because we can’t rely on” the local police. Josol said his station’s journalists were receiving new anonymous threats, including text messages that say, “You’ll be next.”
Marcelo Pintac, director of police for General Santos City, takes issue with such criticism. He said Acharon was dismissed from police service in December 2008 when it became clear the officer was a suspect in the killing. Pintac also insisted that, despite public sightings of Acheron, his officers have not been able to track down the suspect to serve the arrest warrant.
Cuesta’s widow, Gloria, who now travels with two state-appointed bodyguards, has come under pressure to “settle” the case outside of court. She told CPJ that soon after her husband’s murder, she received anonymous text messages offering up to 100,000 pesos to drop the case. In more recent weeks, she said, a longtime acquaintance who claimed to represent the suspects approached her to ask how much it would take to halt the proceedings.
Amid such strong political pressure, many are deeply skeptical that a fair trial can be held in General Santos City courts. Josol noted that the salaries, allowances, and vehicle privileges of local judges are all at the discretion of city hall. Although Mayor Acharon has publicly urged local police to arrest his cousin, many local journalists saw a regional court’s decision in February to reassign the case to another branch as politically motivated. The reassignment, done at the behest of defense, effectively delayed the issuance of an arrest warrant for several weeks. Now, defense lawyer Garcia told CPJ, he will challenge the legality of the current warrant.
WPP head Dacera said defendants often seek to delay proceedings with the intention of breaking the will of witnesses. “We have witnesses that have been in the program for years, and the cases are just gathering dust,” said Dacera, noting that two or three years of delays can produce “procedural nightmares” for the witnesses involved. “By the time the witnesses do finally testify, they often can’t even remember what they put in their affidavits.”
But that’s not the case with Flores, who said that he will never forget the details of the day his colleague was killed at his side. “I will not quit,” he said, “no matter how long it takes.” (By Shawn W. Crispin. The author is CPJ’s senior Southeast Asia representative.)
CPJ’s recommendations to Philippine authorities:
* The legislature and executive branch should ensure adequate funding for the Witness Protection Program. The legislature should appropriate the 140 million pesos sought by President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo to fund the program.
* The judicial system should promptly review and approve motions seeking changes of venue in journalist murder cases. In several cases, public prosecutors and attorneys representing victims’ families have filed these motions to ensure neutral and secure venues.
* National police should take assertive and timely enforcement action in response to all reports of intimidation or bribery of witnesses.
* These steps must be part of a broad, nationwide strategy to aggressively prosecute the killers of journalists. Task Force USIG and local authorities must not only file charges, they must apprehend wanted suspects and build strong evidentiary cases against them.
Link: http://cpj.org/reports/2009/08/philippines-impunity-under-oath-under-threat.php
Tuesday, August 18, 2009
Anti-narcotics agents capture 3 drug pushers in Zamboanga raid
ZAMBOANGA CITY, Philippines (Mindanao Examiner / August 18, 2009) – Philippine anti-narcotics agents clashed with suspected drug pushers and wounded one of them during a raid at a village in the southern port city of Zamboanga City on Tuesday, reports said.
The ABS-CBN television said members of the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency arrested the trio - Farouk Samla, Abu Pandang and Sal Sali – in the village of Recodo.
It quoted Adzhar Albani, regional chief of the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency, as saying that Samla is included in the most wanted list.
Albani said they seized several sacks of drug paraphernalia and plastic sachets containing suspected methamphetamine hydrochloride or locally known as shabu.
Last year, anti-narcotics agents, backed by policemen, also raided a suspected shabu laboratory on a remote village in Zamboanga City.
Police said the laboratory was being operated by a Taiwanese man and his Filipino cohorts in the village of Lamisahan. It was the first time that authorities have discovered a shabu laboratory in Zamboanga.
Shabu is a clear, chunky form of crystals resembling ice and is sometimes referred to as "crystal" or glass" by drug users.
The drug releases high levels of stimulant dopamine that works on brain cells to activate body movement and elevate moods. When used regularly it has a neurological toxic effect and can damage brain cells.
Police said obnoxious smell from the laboratory and the contaminated water from a creek nearby gave away the illegal operation. (Mindanao Examiner)
House Speaker Gets Plaque Of Appreciation From Mindanao Regional Advisory Committee
participants and people of Mindanao during a simple rite at the Andaya Hall at the Batasan Complex in Manila on Tuesday, August 18, 2000. (Photo by Gil Bugaoisan)
Moro Women Finish Seminar On Poll Reforms, Other Issues In Zamboanga City
ZAMBOANGA CITY, Philippines (Mindanao Examiner / August 18, 2009) – More than 20 Moro women leaders from Basilan, Sulu and Tawi-Tawi provinces in the southern Philippines gathered in Zamboanga City recently for a two-day training that tackled issues on electoral reforms and poll violence.
The paramount sultan of Sulu, Dr Ibrahim Bahjin Shakirulla II, highlighted the opening program with an inspirational talk. Various topics were discussed by different guest and resource speakers.
With the theme “Enhancing Moro Women’s Capacity to Mitigate Electoral Violence,” Merci Angeles, president of the group called Peace Women Partners-Manila, talked on the orientation on women, peace and security, while Professor Aisa Akalal, who is the president of Sinag Kababaihan, gave a situational report about the women in Basilan, Sulu and Tawi-Tawi.
Professor Akalal said that the seminar was organized by the Sinag Kababaihan in partnership with The Asia Foundation.
“This is a wake up call to all Moro women in Mindanao in general to empower themselves to play their vital role in mitigating electoral violence particularly in the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao,” said Professor Akalal.
A survey conducted last year by the Social Weather Station showed that 69% of the respondents agree that “violence during elections is accepted as a way of life in their province.”
SWS President Dr Mahar Mangahas described the finding as “very, very alarming.”
The survey also showed that 61% of the respondents find election-related violence serious in their locality with 20% saying “very serious” and 41% referring to it as “somewhat serious.”
In terms of personal security during election time, 43% of the respondents within the ARMM said they were worried about the situation compared with 33% in areas outside the Muslim autonomous region.
Other speakers during the training were Professor Octavio Dinampo, Irene Santiago, the Chief Executive Officer of the Mindanao Commission on Women; Provincial Vice Governor Hajja Ruby Sahali-Tan of Tawi-Tawi, Dr Samsula Adju, former Chancellor of the Mindanao State University in Sulu province; Professor Fred Concepcion, editor-in-chief of the Sulu provincial newsletter, the Sulu Gazette; and Hajja Babylyn Kano-Omar, the station manager of dxGD-Radio for Peace in the town of Bongao in Tawi-Tawi province.
Participants to the training agreed to actively commit and get involved in the advocacy to mitigate electoral violence in Basilan, Sulu and Tawi-Tawi in the 2010 local and national elections. Moro women from Tawi-Tawi have expressed their enthusiasm to host the same training activity in the future. (Amilbahar Mawallil)
Liderato ng MILF, hati kay Manny Pacquiao!
COTABATO CITY (Mindanao Examiner / August 18, 2009) – Hati ang opinyon ng liderato ng Moro Islamic Liberation Front sa proposal na gawin negosyador ang Pinoy boxing legend na si Manny Pacquiao.
Mismong si Senator Aquilino Pimentel ang nagpalutang ng proposal dahil umano sa katanyagan ni Pacquiao. Ngunit sa panig naman ni MILF chief peace negotiator Mohagher Iqbal ay dapat sapat umano ang kaalaman ni Pacquiao upang maintindihan ang problema ng mga Muslim sa Mindanao.
Pabor naman si Pacquiao na tumulong sa pamahalaan para sa kapakanan ng bansa at ng peace process.
Hindi naman mabatid kung makaka-apekto ba ang pagiging Army reservist ni Pacquiao sa kanyang role bilang negosyador kung sakaling patusin ng Malakanyang ang proposal ni Pimentel. Si Pacquiao ay isang sarhento sa reserve command ng Philippine Army.
Maaring manganib rin ang buhay ni Pacquiao dahil baka ito madukot habang nakikipagusap sa mga rebelde at ipatubos sa kanyang pamilya.
Sinabi naman sa Mindanao Examiner ni Eid Kabalu, isang senior MILF leader, na walang masama kung tumulong si Pacquiao sa peace talks.
“With all due respect, kahit saan galing ang good idea that will contribute to the resolution of the Bangsamoro problem is welcome. Kahit sino basta makakatulong sa kapayapaan ay welcome,” ani pa ni Kabalu.
Ngunti sinabi ni Kabalu na kung talagang sinsero ang Malakanyang na gamitin si Pacquiao bilang isa sa mga negosyador ay dapat itong pormal na ihain sa peace panel.
Idinagdag pa ni Kabalu na sa sobrang yaman ni Pacquiao ay pede itong makakatulong sa maraming mahihirap na Muslim sa Mindanao. “It’s good if he can spend some of his wealth for the improvement of the lives of our poor people in Mindanao,” wika ni Kabalu. (Mindanao Examiner)
Sulu Praises US support to peace and development; hails Obama
ZAMBOANGA CITY, Philippines (Mindanao Examiner / August 18, 2009) – Sulu Governor Sakur Tan praised the United States on Tuesday for its continuing support to peace and development in the province.
Tan said the United States Agency for International Development donated thousands of books and reference materials on Monday through US Ambassador Kristie Kenny.
“We thank President Barack Obama and Ambassador Kristie Kenney and the people of the United States and all those who continue to help us through various humanitarian projects and peace and development programs for Sulu,” he told reporters.
Tan said a book fair was also held on Tuesday and attended by hundreds of teachers and students.
The USAID is an independent government agency that provides economic development and humanitarian assistance to advance US economic and political interests overseas.
Kenney for her part pledged to continue peace and development supports to Sulu, one of five provinces under the Muslim autonomous region, Tan said.
He said Kenney also led US officials in the inauguration of the multi-million two-storey building of the Area Coordination Center near the Provincial Capitol in Patikul town.
The ACC coordinate Sulu’s various non-governmental agencies, military, police, emergency services and other organizations and serves as an inter-agency communication network.
Tan said the ACC is a facility established as a proactive, reactive, and post conflict mechanism to address various concerns at regional and local levels of governance and to solve problems of coordination and response.
The ACC functions both as a system and as a council for planning, integrating, directing, supervising, and implementing line-up government programs and projects particularly on political, socioeconomic, cultural, religious, development, security and information issues, said Fazlur-Rahman Abdulla, ACC Executive Director.
“The newly-inaugurated ACC is worth more than P20 million and was funded by the United States government. We have now a total of 20 Area Coordinating Centers – one for each of Sulu’s 19 towns and the central ACC headquarters in Patikul town. The Tausug people appreciate President Obama's assistance and the US government's continued support to our efforts to sustain peace and development in Sulu,” Abdulla told the Mindanao Examiner by phone on Tuesday.
U.S. troops are deployed in Sulu on the request of the Philippine government, to train and advise the local military. They are also active in humanitarian missions and were working alongside with Filipino soldiers in development projects on poor areas in Jolo. (Jung Francisco)
Monday, August 17, 2009
Davao City Residents Get Free Medical Care Cards



Nograles’ son and chief of staff, lawyer Karlo Nograles, led the weekend distribution of the PhilHealth cards mostly to poor residents of the city’s first congressional district where the solon belongs.
The distribution of the medical care cards was held at the covered court in the village of Matina.
The cards will provide its holders with free medical care from the Philippine Health Insurance Corporation, an attached agency under the Department of Health.
The young Nograles said it was part of his father’s “Oplan Kaalam” program which will benefit poor families.
“Having a PhilHealth card is a great help especially to the poor because they can use this card in their hospitalization,” he told the Mindanao Examiner.
He said the money paid to avail the cards came from the solon’s Priority Development Assistance Fund.
The lawyer said thousands of PhilHealth cards were already released to local residents in recent years.
The distribution of PhilHealth cards was originally started by President Gloria Arroyo and continued by the House Speaker to help the poor, who cannot afford to pay the medical care premiums.
With the PhilHealth card, the enrolled families may avail themselves of the regular hospitalization benefit package provided by the agency in any of its accredited hospitals and other institutional health care providers in the country. (Geo Solmerano)
House Speaker Prospero Nograles administers oath of office to new solon
Troops recover army, police uniforms used by rebels in Mindanao
DAVAO CITY, Philippines (Mindanao Examiner / August 17, 2009) – Government troops have recovered military and police uniforms believed used by communist rebels in their operations in the southern Philippines, officials said on Monday.
Officials said soldiers recovered two dozen pairs of camouflage and police uniforms, three pair of combat boots and a megaphone in the village of Casoon in Compostela Valley’s Monkayo town over the weekend.
Captain Rosa Maria Cristina Manuel, a spokeswoman for the 10th Infantry Division, said villages tipped off the military about the uniforms left by New People’s Army rebels.
She said rebels often use army and police uniform to disguise themselves and raid military and police posts in the southern Philippines.
“They use these military and police uniform to disguise them selves as soldiers and policemen and to be able to conduct terrorist activities,” Manuel told the Mindanao Examiner.
She said troops were sent to the town to track down rebel forces, blamed for the spate of attacks in the province in recent months.
The NPA is fighting the past four decades for the establishment of a Maoist state in the country. (Geo Solmerano)
Keeping in touch with the news
House Speaker denies claims that President used up P800M fund for foreign trips
MANILA, Philippines - House Speaker Prospero Nograles said Representative Teofisto Guingona III may have exaggerated when he claimed there was a report by the Commission on Audit submitted to his office on which he based his allegation that President Gloria Arroyo used up the government’s P800-million contingency fund for her foreign trips.
Nograles said that while he holds great respect for Guingona, he may have exaggerated his claim on an alleged COA report submitted to his office and may have twisted some information when he and other select members of the House of Representatives were briefed by COA.
“There was never any such report. I have not received any such report and I think the same is true with other members of the House. We have not received any official communication from the COA to that effect - not even in the COA briefing that was supposed to be given only for select House leaders, where Representative Guingona sat,” Nograles said.
“Even the COA presentors were caught unaware about such a supposed COA report. He may have blown out of proportion his extrapolations based on limited information,” he added.
Nograles said the presentation of Assistant Commissioner Carmela Perez did not specify anything about the President's travels although it included the issue on allotments that exceeded appropriations for some Special Purpose Funds (SPF) of which Contingent Fund was one of the items.
In terms of the total travel expenses supposedly amounting to P2.7 billion as claimed by Guingona, Nograles said the research done by his staff may have included all agencies under the Office of the President.
“This is very different from attributing all of the travel expenses to the President herself,” Nograles said.
“Over 3 dozen agencies report to the Office of the President, which require also foreign travels in the course of their work. Their expenses may have been inadvertently attributed by the research staff of Rep. Guingona to the person of the President,” he added.
Sunday, August 16, 2009
Respect human rights, military and rebels told
MANILA, Philippines - The Commission on Human Rights on Sunday called on the military and rebel forces in Basilan to respect human rights and humanitarian law even as they engage in combat, and urged the government to quickly assist civilians affected by the fighting.
This came after reports that President Gloria Arroyo ordered the Armed Forces to "annihilate the Abu Sayyaf" armed group in Mindanao.
“Armed battle is not an excuse for anyone to violate the human dignity of opposing forces or to violate the rights of civilians,”said CHR Chairperson Leila De Lima.
“Its particularly ironic that this battle and reported atrocities such as hacking at soldiers were committed at the very same time the CHR was holding a National Summit on International Humanitarian Law to celebrate the 60th Anniversary of the Geneva Conventions which is on August 12th,” she said.
De Lima said the CHR will work to bring the Summit recommendations to policy and action by the relevant actors, including rebel groups.
Among the results of the Summit, participants from various sectors including the government and uniformed services called on all parties to armed conflict to respect IHL and the rights of protected persons such as civilians, medical personnel and non-combatants even if they belong to one of the fighting sides. Prisoners of war and wounded soldiers belong to this latter group.
2 Philippine military choppers hit by enemy fire in Basilan province



A military photo shows a pilot inspecting one of two Philippine Air Force UH-1H choppers hit by enemy fire on Sunday, August 16, 2009 while flying over the southern province of Basilan, scene of a recent fighting that killed 43 soldiers and Abu Sayyaf militants. (Mindanao Examiner)ZAMBOANGA CITY, Philippines (Mindanao Examiner / August 16, 2009) – Two Philippine military helicopters came under fire Sunday and were forced to land on a remote village in the southern province of Basilan, officials said.
Officials said two television cameramen for the state-run NBN Television who were filming with senior military commanders were hurt in the landing near Lamitan City.
There were no reports of serious injuries, but the choppers were hit by bullets believed fired from automatic rifles.
“The choppers, both UH1H, were flying over Lamitan when it came under fire. We still don’t know who were behind the attack – it could be the Abu Sayyaf or Moro rebels,” said Army First Lieutenant Steffani Cacho, a spokeswoman for the Western Mindanao Command.
Cacho did not say how many passengers were in the aircrafts, but among them were a marine general and his aides.
She said the choppers were heading to the Kurelem, scene of a recent fighting between government troops and Abu Sayyaf militants in the town of Ungkaya Pukan. The fighting on Wednesday killed at least 43 soldiers and militants.
No individual of group claimed responsibility for the attack that occurred at around 11.30 a.m. near the village of Tumasib. Military operations against the Abu Sayyaf still continue in Basilan, several nautical miles south of Zamboanga City. (Mindanao Examiner)
The Asia Foundation donates books to Lanao del Sur
MARAWI CITY, Philippines – Some 35,000 brand new books were distributed Sunday to 740 public elementary and high schools across Lanao Del Sur province in an effort to expand and improve access to educational materials.
Lanao Del Sur Provincial Library benefited from the donation of books which is made possible by The Asia Foundation’s Books for Asia program and distributed in Mindanao through the Foundation’s Transparent Accountable Governance project, with support from the United States Agency for International Development (USAID).
Governor Mamintal Adiong, Jr., officials of the provincial government, and staff of the Department of Education attended the handover ceremony.
Officials from USAID and from The Asia Foundation, including Ky Johnson, Deputy Country Representative and Efren Balajadia, Director of the Books for Asia program, presented the books to representatives of the 740 elementary and secondary schools at the event.
“We are working in solidarity with local leaders and citizens to distribute books to all communities, but especially in Mindanao, so that all scholars - rich and poor,Muslims and Christians - have access to reading materials and information,” said Johnson. “Through this donation, the people of Lanao Del Sur will have access to educational resources that will enhance their knowledge and skills in order to promote literacy in every community.”
USAID also supported the book distribution in Lanao Del Sur in response to the need for educational materials in Mindanao. Books for Asia provides a full range of books to public school students with different levels of learning.
The provision of books and other educational resources demonstrates commitment in the campaign to improving education in communities in the southern part of the Philippines.
Johnson noted the Foundation’s support to local communities in Mindanao and other parts of the Philippines to improve the quality of education dates back to the 1950s.
“With the cooperation of local governments and private partners, we can help each community bring educational materials to deserving students throughout southern Mindanao and the rest of the Philippines,” he said.
The Asia Foundation acknowledges the important support of public and private partners in this endeavor, especially the Provincial Government of Lanao Del Sur for encouraging activities that promote education and literacy American publishers like The McGraw-Hill Companies, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, and Pearson Education for their donation of new books, as well as USAID for generously supporting Books for Asia’s efforts to foster education throughout Mindanao.
Saturday, August 15, 2009
Arroyo visits wounded troops; condoles with families of slain soldiers in Mindanao




Arroyo, accompanied by Defense Secretary Gilberto Teodoro and Armed Forces chief General Victor Ibrado, also visited wounded soldiers at a military hospital at the Western Mindanao Command headquarters where she handed cash assistance
She spoke with the families of the slain soldiers and awarded posthumous medals and money worth more than seven million pesos. Arroyo later presided over a command conference with senior military and police commanders.
Teodoro said the President ordered the military to wipe out the Abu Sayyaf, blamed for the spate of terrorism and kidnappings-for-ransom in the southern Philippines.
“The President’s order is to wipe out the Abu Sayyaf,” the Defense Secretary told reporters.
Troops on Wednesday stormed an Abu Sayyaf camp in the village of Silangkum in Basilan’s Ungkaya Pukan town, but security forces also clashed with Moro Islamic Liberation Front rebels in the neighboring village of Baguindan.
The MILF said soldiers attacked its forces without provocation, an accusation denied by the military. The MILF is the country’s largest Muslim rebel group fighting for self-determination in the South. The fighting killed 23 soldiers and 20 militants and rebels. (Mindanao Examiner)
Friday, August 14, 2009
Notre Dame, COMELEC Urge Students To Register For 2010 Polls

The Commission on Elections in Kidapawan City in North Cotabato province set up a mobile voter’s registration center at the Notre Dame College. The school and the poll body have urged students who are eligible to vote to register and exercise their rights of suffrage. (Mindanao Examiner Photo / Geo Solmerano)KIDAPAWAN CITY, North Cotabato (Mindanao Examiner / August 14, 2009) - The Notre Dame College of Kidapawan and the Commission on Elections have urged students who are eligible to vote next year to register and exercise their rights of suffrage.
The Commission on Elections in Kidapawan City set up a mobile voter’s registration center at the Notre Dame College in an effort to hasten the registration of students.
Civilians were also allowed by the Notre Dame to register with the Commission on Elections.
Filipinos are to elect their local and national officials in next year's polls. (Arlene Solmerano)
Fighting subsides in southern Philippines; military gives honors to 23 slain soldiers




Family members weep Friday, August 14, 2009 as they view the remains of a soldier inside a gym in Zamboanga City in the southern Philippines. The military says 23 soldiers and 20 Abu Sayyaf militants were killed in Wednesday fighting in Basilan province.“There have been no reports of fighting in Basilan, but military operations against the Abu Sayyaf still continue,” said Marine Major General Benjamin Dolorfino, commander of military forces in Mindanao.
Troops stormed an Abu Sayyaf camp in the hinterland village of Silangkum in Ungkaya Pukan town on Wednesday and seized weapons and improvised explosives. But soldiers also clashed with a group of Moro Islamic Liberation Front rebels in the neighboring village of Baguindan that sparked daylong clashes that also killed 10 gunmen.
The MILF, which is currently negotiating peace with Manila, accused government soldiers of attacking the rebels. It said troops also mutilated the bodies of three of rebels, including a senior MILF leader, killed in the clashes.
Dolorfino denied the MILF accusations. “That’s not true,” he told the Mindanao Examiner.
On Friday, Dolorfino led funeral honors for the slain soldiers in Zamboanga City along with Defense Secretary Gilberto Teodoro and Armed Forces chief General Victor Ibrado.
Relatives and families of killed soldiers weep as fellow soldiers pay their last respect to the fallen marines and infantrymen. Coffins of soldiers were paraded inside the Western Mindanao Command headquarters where hundreds of soldiers and civilian employees lined up a road leading to the gymnasium where the caskets are put on display for public viewing.
“What did they do to our boy? He’s such a young soldier. He doesn’t deserve this brutality,” cried one woman.
And just across the woman, family members also gathered and weeping around a coffin of a soldier, whose face was deformed because of what looked like a hack wound. Two other caskets were closed to hide the wounds in the faces of the slain soldiers, both marines.
Lieutenant Colonel Gamal Hayudini, commander of the military’s 4th Civil Relations Group, said MILF gunmen engaged government troops, who were pursuing the Abu Sayyaf, in a firefight despite an earlier coordination between the military and the rebel group.
“The government forces were confident with the on-going peace negotiation, thus, making the troops believe that nothing will really happen since the MILF was informed of the pursuit operations but unexpectedly, they engaged in firefight with our forces. The MILF should not mislead the people by always passing on the blame to the government forces,” he said.
The MILF is the country’s largest Muslim rebel group which is fighting the past three decades for self-determination.
President Gloria Arroyo opened up peace talks with the MILF in 2001 in an effort to put an end to the bloody fighting in Mindanao. (Mindanao Examiner)
Thursday, August 13, 2009
Parents-Teachers Association: A reliable school partner in delivery of basic education
ZAMBOANGA CITY, Philippines - Heads of public elementary and secondary schools with their teachers as well as members of school parents-teachers associations have long been considered by the Department of Education as strong and vital partners in the educational development of children.
That is why, the DepEd regularly issues to the field necessary guidelines and policies designed to further strengthen the partnership of the two groups that work together 365 days a year to ensure effective and efficient delivery of quality basic education.
Needless to say, school heads and their teachers and PTA members must find time to study these PTA-related DepEd directives to well sustain their harmonious relationship and camaraderie with one another and ultimately avoid unnecessary misunderstanding.
Education Secretary Jesli A. Lapus in June issued DepEd Order No. 54 entitled “Revised Guidelines Governing Parents-Teachers Associations (PTAs) at the School Level.”
Lapus’ order contains several vital guidelines which every right-thinking school head, teacher or PTA member should attempt to always remember since these guidelines are considered by DepEd as the “unofficial” Bible of the organization of teachers and parents in a community school.
The first guideline concerns the election of school PTA executive officers which, unlike in previous school years were chosen at large during a General Assembly, has been mandated by Lapus that these same executive officers, starting school year 2009-2010, should now be elected by presidents of Homeroom PTA earlier selected by their own classroom PTA members.
Lapus further stipulated that all elected Homeroom PTA presidents in a particular elementary or secondary school shall elect a school PTA board of directors composed of 15 members who later will, in turn, choose from among themselves the PTA’s executive officers.
These PTA executive officers are identified by Lapus as the President, Vice President, Treasurer, Secretary, Auditor and other equivalent positions such as business manager, sergeant-at-arms and public information officer. Their main function is to oversee the activities of the association for one year.
Each of the PTA executive officers has a term of only one school year and cannot hold the same position for more than two terms to give other deserving PTA members a chance to help run the organization, Lapus said, adding that the adviser of the PTA is the school head while the PTA secretary should preferably be a teacher.
According to the DepEd chief, the PTA Grand Assembly – composed of all parents, teachers and non-teaching personnel --- shall be convened by the PTA board of directors at least twice a year in coordination with the school head as to the time, venue and other details.
The PTA Assembly, Lapus said, shall discuss PTA programs, projects, financial statement and other concerns during which a local government official or civic group leader may be invited as resource persons.
The education secretary also stipulated that the PTA Board of Directors is authorized to form necessary committees to handle specific association activities such as Committees on Finance, on Programs and Projects, on Grievance, on Ways and Means, and on External and Community Affairs whose committee heads may come from the Board members or Homeroom PTA Presidents.
A PTA may or may not be incorporated with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), Lapus said, adding that a Division PTA Affairs Committee, chaired by the schools superintendents, shall be created to monitor various school PTA activities in the city or province.
The collection of voluntary contributions from parent-members should be subject to pertinent DepEd issuances and regulations.
He said that PTA contributions shall be collected by the PTA Treasurer on a per-parent-member basis regardless of the number of their children in school and that no collection of PTA contribution shall be done during enrolment period.
The non-payment of contributions, Lapus stressed, shall not be a basis for the non-admission of or non-issuance of clearances to students.
Lapus also required the PTA Treasurer to deposit all collections of contributions in a reputable bank determined by the PTA Board of Directors even as he emphasized that all disbursements of funds shall be in accordance with accepted accounting and auditing regulations.
The DepEd secretary mandated that “in no case shall any school head or personnel be entrusted with the safekeeping and disbursement of collection. Lapus further directed that PTA Annual Financial statement signed by the President, Treasurer and Auditor shall be submitted to the school head not later than 30 days after the last day classes.
Furthermore, Lapus required the PTA to submit to the School Head not later than Nov. 30 a mid-school year financial statement report every October 30. He stressed that failure to submit such financial statement shall be ground for the cancellation of the recognition of the PTA by the Division PTA Committee upon the recommendation of the School Head. (By Lutchi Castelo-Rimando. The author is the Principal of the Culianan National High School in Zamboanga City.)
Construction Firm To Sue Zambo Mayor, City Officials Over Controversial Bus Depot Project
Arroyo entourage also had $15,000 meal in D.C. - Report
MANILA - Three days before allegedly spending $20,000 for a dinner in a Manhattan restaurant, President Arroyo and her entourage also reportedly spent another $15,000 for dinner at Bobby Van's Steakhouse on 15th Street, Washington DC, a major US daily reported Wednesday.
A report titled "Heartburn Over Two Big Meals" in the Washington Post's Reliable Source column said Mrs. Arroyo and an entourage of about 65 people, including security and food tasters, had dinner at Bobby Van's Steakhouse on 15th Street NW hours after her July 30 meeting with US President Barack Obama.
"The group took over one of the restaurant's private rooms and dined on lobster, steak and fine wines; at the conclusion of the meal, an unidentified woman opened a handbag stuffed with cash, counted out bills and paid the $15,000 tab -- which included a generous tip," the column read.
"The Philippine Embassy did not return calls for comment Tuesday," it added.
The bill of $15,000 roughly translates to about P720,899,000 based on latest foreign exchange rates.
Steaks at the popular restaurant are priced anywhere from $38 (P1,830) to $42 (P2,023), according to the Bobby Van's Steakhouse website. Half bottles of red and white wine at the restaurant are priced between $18 (P867) to $60 (P2,890) while the most expensive bottle on the winelist, a Louis Roederer Cristal Reims, is priced at $575 (P27,697).
Arroyo's expensive dinner in Washington is the second to be reported by the US media recently. Last week, the New York Post reported that Arroyo and her entourage dined at Manhattan's Le Cirque on August 2, with the dinner bill amounting to $20,000 or almost P1 million.
Malacañang spokesmen have denied that public funds were used to pay for the dinner. They said it was Leyte Rep. Ferdinand Martin Romualdez who paid the bill. Romualdez is the nephew of former First Lady Imelda Marcos.
Akbayan party-list Rep. Walden Bello on Wednesday urged the Office of the Ombudsman to investigate President Arroyo for violating Republic Act 6713 or the Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees.
Bello cited Section 4(h) of the law which states that “public officials shall lead modest lives appropriate to their positions and income,” and that “they shall not engage in extravagant or ostentatious displays of wealth."
He added that if Romualdez paid for the dinner, then both Arroyo and Romualdez could be charged with bribery.(Link: http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/nation/08/12/09/report-arroyo-entourage-also-had-15000-meal-dc)
Heartburn Over Two Big Meals: The Washington Post
Philippine President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo's visit to the White House on July 30 didn't draw much attention, and her dinner in Washington that night got nary a mention. And that's how it might have stayed -- if not for a controversial meal in New York City.
Arroyo is under fire in her native country for a $20,000 meal at Manhattan's Le Cirque on Aug. 2, which included caviar and several bottles of champagne. The dinner, first reported in the New York Post, has Arroyo's critics comparing her to the extravagant Imelda Marcos.
The Reliable Source has learned that three days earlier, Arroyo and an entourage of about 65 people (including security and food tasters) had dinner at Bobby Van's Steakhouse on 15th Street NW hours after she met with President Obama. The group took over one of the restaurant's private rooms and dined on lobster, steak and fine wines; at the conclusion of the meal, an unidentified woman opened a handbag stuffed with cash, counted out bills and paid the $15,000 tab -- which included a generous tip.
The Philippine Embassy did not return calls for comment Tuesday.
Link: http://voices.washingtonpost.com/reliable-source/2009/08/rs-dinner12.html
Freedom of Information: Good Theory, Bad Practice
Journalists are among those usually denied access to public information despite the Constitutional guarantee. Information is either confidential or no longer available, leaving them and more so the people clueless on how their country is being run. (Photo by Claire Delfin)The trend has moreover widened under the administration of President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo according to Attorney Nepomuceno Malaluan, co-convenor of the Access to Information Network (ATIN).
“While the long-standing problems cut across all previous regimes, this current administration has displayed an alarming swing towards institutional secrecy,” Malaluan says.
For instance, party-list group Akbayan was met with flat denials to access the text of the proposed agreement during the recent negotiation of the controversial Japan-Philippines Economic Partnership Agreement, a bilateral trade and investment treaty between Japan and the Philippines.
The same also happened to the Transparency and Accountability Network (TAN), which was refused access to the report of retired Supreme Court Chief Justice Hilario Davide Jr. on electoral reforms. The report was seen as significant for TAN, which advocates for electoral reforms.
Malacañang Palace likewise sought to restrict access to the report of the Independent Commission to Address Media and Activist Killings, but eventually gave in after persistent calls from cause-oriented groups.
Denials of access to various government loan agreements and government contracts has been a consistent practice despite a specific provision in the Bill of Rights that requires information on foreign loans obtained or guaranteed by the government to be made available to the public.
Journalists, too
Journalists are not exempted from routine refusals to block access to information despite the country being perceived as enjoying a relatively free press.
“Every journalist who’s had to look for information from public agencies has a horror story to tell -- or at least a frustrating and infuriating tale which usually includes being given the run around and being told outright that certain public records are ‘confidential,’ or that the particular agency just does not release the information being sought,” writes journalism professor Luis Teodoro in his article on access to information - The Key is in the Exemptions.
In most cases, he says, journalists have to settle with non-traditional and informal approaches in getting the required information.
Ed Lingao of the Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism (PCIJ) agrees and adds: “Parang utang na loob mo pang mabigyan ng impormasyon (It’s like you owe them a debt of gratitude if you’re given the information).”
In the last 10 years, PCIJ has documented 14 major instances when they were met with “flimsy excuses” from 12 national agencies in their effort to secure public information relating to its investigative reporting.
In its article entitled “Multiple requests for access to info meet with flat denials,” PCIJ says these requested data and documents included civil work contracts, contractors of government projects, loan agreements, and the assets and liabilities and net worth (SALNs) of justices of the Supreme Court, generals of the Armed Forces and the political appointees of Malacañang and other executive agencies.
Requests for information were made in writing three to five times, and were followed up by as much as 18 to 21 phone calls to the agencies concerned. PCIJ also had to deal with 6 to 9 various officials in the same agencies, and had to wait for 56 days to six months to get any response on its requests.
The situation for those journalists in the provinces is worse. Typically they are referred by local agencies to the national office to obtain public documents.
Things got worse for journalists on February 24, 2006 when President Arroyo issued Presidential Proclamation 1017 which placed the country under a state of emergency amid an alleged plot by “military adventurists.” The order sought to limit the functions of the press to report issues that the government deemed to be precarious to national security.
It went on with a statement from then chairman of the National Telecommunications Commission, Ronald Solis that the government could shut down any television or a radio station during a state of emergency.
President Arroyo lifted the proclamation a week later after reported pressure from economic advisers who maintained the country’s business reputation was suffering.
Red Batario, executive director of the Center for Community Journalism and Development, says information kept secret is a legacy of Marcos martial rule that has lingered on.
Harder for ordinary folks
Ordinary members of the public meanwhile have an even harder time securing their rights to public information than journalists.
“The poor are still chained to the shackles of ignorance. Aside from organized citizens groups and people’s organizations, a large majority of poor Filipinos are unable to claim their rights simply because they don’t know how, and what these are, to begin with,” writes Batario in his article “Our Right to Know.”
Batario adds that information, when democratized and made widely available, allows citizens to actively participate on issues that have serious repercussions for governance.
“The ouster of Joseph Estrada midway through his presidency illustrates the potent power of the information when citizens, shocked by the proceedings of the impeachment trial covered extensively by the press, took the streets to call for his resignation.”
But Batario also lauds certain practices in some places in the Philippines. The Ulat sa Banwaan (Report to the People) of Albay province and Batad in Iloilo are few examples of how active citizen participation has opened up information flows and helped to ensure greater transparency in local government processes.
Information Law
But as these models come in extremely short supply, a Freedom of Information Act becomes necessary, says ATIN.
It adds it is only through an informed press and citizenry that Filipinos can effectively and reasonably participate at all levels of social, political and economic decision-making.
The proposed law was passed in the House of Representatives last year, but it has languished in the Senate.
Among others, House Bill 3732 provides clear, uniform, and speedy procedure for public access to information. It also provides mechanics for the compulsory duty of government agencies to disclose information on government transactions.
The bill enumerates a narrow list of clearly defined and reasonable exceptions. While the general rule is that all information in the hands of government must be accessible to the public, it adds that there are times when it is in the public interest to keep some information confidential – for example ongoing criminal operations.
But the bill also allows an opportunity and right for citizens to override an exception whenever there is greater public interest in the disclosure of information.
It provides clear criminal liabilities for violation of the right to information, and at the same time, adequate and accessible remedies when cases of this nature arise.
And more importantly, the bill spells out numerous mechanisms for the active promotion of openness in government, which is seen as a vital safeguard against rampant corruption that has weighed down the country’s economic performance.
“Secrecy in government has given public officials a wide room for maneuver and greater cover for corruption,” says ATIN’s Malaluan. It is widely reported and accepted that more than 20 per cent of the country’s annual budget is lost to corruption and mismanagement, thanks to an annual budget process that is so lacking in transparency and oversight.
Nevertheless, ATIN remains optimistic that the bill can still be passed before the 14th Congress ends next year. The Senate may be lacklustre and sluggish but it does not, so far, harbour any strong opposition against the bill.
And that is a good sign for advocates to push the bill’s passage much forward. After all, there is no better time -- than now -- to claim that most basic of rights, the right to information.(By Claire Delfin. The author is a television news reporter of GMA Network, Inc. and is a regular contributor of special reports on women, children, education, health, human rights, and the environment to the network’s news website GMANews.TV.)
Link: http://www.rightsreporting.net/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=6998&Itemid=130
Dozens killed in fighting in southern Philippines



Relatives in Zamboanga City view Thursday, August 13, 2009 the caskets of soldiers killed in fierce clashes in Basilan province in the southern Philippines. And a photo released by the military shows Western Mindanao Command chief, Major General Benjamin Dolorfino, as he pins a medal to a wounded soldier while a regional navy chief, Admiral Alexander Pama looks on, at a military hospital in Zamboanga City. Fighting in Basilan province on Wednesday left 23 soldiers dead and 20 Abu Sayyaf militants and 19 more security men wounded. (Mindanao Examiner Photo).ZAMBOANGA CITY, Philippines (Mindanao Examiner / August 13, 2009) – At least 43 soldiers and militants were killed in fierce clashes in the southern Filipino province of Basilan, where security forces stormed an Abu Sayyaf camp.
The fighting, which began Wednesday, also left more than a dozen soldiers wounded in the town of Ungkaya Pukan after security forces stormed an Abu Sayyaf camp in Silangkum village.
Soldiers recovered at least 10 bodies of slain militants and improvised explosives and high-powered weapons from the Abu Sayyaf camp, said First Lieutenant Steffani Cacho, a regional army spokeswoman.
She said troops were fighting the Abu Sayyaf, blamed for the spate of terrorism and kidnappings for ransom in Basilan and nearby city of Zamboanga.
Troops on Thursday continued their hunt for the militants in the hinterland villages of Baguindan and Silangkum in the town of Ungkaya Pukan where the fighting erupted.
Military sources in Basilan said 23 soldiers, including two army lieutenants, and 20 militants were killed in the daylong fighting. The cadavers of the soldiers were brought to the Western Mindanao Command in Zamboanga City.
But Moro Islamic Liberation Front which is negotiating peace with Manila said troops also clashed with rebel forces in Baguindan village.
“Troops attacked MILF forces in the village and this triggered fierce clashes. Nine of our members and more than 20 government soldiers were killed in the fighting,” Eid Kabalu, a senior MILF leader, told the Mindanao Examiner.
Kabalu said troops ambushed a group of rebels led by Asid Sali and a firefight ensued. “Commander Sali’s group was on their way to another MILF camp when troops ambushed them and that’s it,” he said.
“The Western Mindanao Command launched a decisive law enforcement operation targeting the Abu Sayyaf main training camp in the province. Recovered from the camp were sizeable quantities of IEDs rigged to explode while others were ready for use,” Cacho said, adding at least 13 high-powered firearms were also seized by soldiers in the militant’s base.
Cacho said the MILF was informed about the offensive operation against the Abu Sayyaf. “We have coordinated with the MILF and the Coordinating Committee for the Cessation of Hostilities to avoid clashes between rebels and troops in Basilan. Our operation targeted the Abu Sayyaf,” she said.
The MILF is the country’s largest Muslim rebel group which is fighting the past three decades for self-determination. Rebels are actively operating in Basilan. (Mindanao Examiner)